I know I'm posting this a bit late.. with the show being over and all.. but I think it was great. Looking back, I also think it could have been done a little better in the sense of protraying the Cylons a little more, and a bit more space graphics other then the fleet flying. Don't get me wrong.. they portrayed the cylons plenty.. but in my opinion, nothing major or groundbreaking has been done in this show that hasn't already been done before. I would have loved to see for example, how the cylon base ship took down the resurrection hub, etc.. I wanted to see the bridge interaction like in star trek, and how they control fighters (from the cylon's side) rather then from Galactica's bridge or cylons as enemies.
That's just my little input on this, other then that, I think the show was great. They also left with a bit of a cliffhanger, because they showed that some other power was in control of everything, and its not the cylons, but yet this power has the ability to exist 150,000 years into the future and knows all about the original homeworld, the twelve colonies, and earth. And why would they abandon all technology? Why not keep/land the ships? Why throw everyone into the stone age, without even the basic communication ability or medicines. I think that's just outright dumb (forgive the expression).